After it was confirmed that the Zelda series actually sat on one cohesive timeline, the internet ran abuzz with speculation about the order of games. With the release of Skyward Sword, everything can begin to fit into place. In fact, I find it quite easy to deduce the Zelda timeline with just the knowledge that Skyward Sword is the first in line. With the origin of the myth understood, I want to look at how the world of Hyrule shifts and changes throughout the ages in all dimensions, using geographic knowledge, the study of names, and a look at the comparative anatomy of those that we find throughout the series. That being said, let me begin by stating the order of the games.
Skyward Sword, Twilight Princess, OoT, and Wind Waker.
Yes, I'll be looking only at the 3D Zelda titles. They are the most major releases of the past fifteen years, and make up the grand framework of the Zelda franchise. I can't say that I've already played every Zelda, and so I am not in a position to comment on every title. But the 3D Zeldas often garner the most interest because each is such a monumentous occasion. Each also carries more of the mythos than the other titles. Ages/Seasons feels out of place, Majora is a direct sequel to OoT, the two DS titles are direct WW sequels, and so forth. I feel like comparing only the four major 3D titles will provide a good 90% of the framework for really digging into the evolution of the Legend of Zelda and how it adapts over time.
I also think that such an examination may be unprecedented in games as a whole. I've yet to think of another franchise of games that so eagerly spans thousands of years in its breadth, and I believe that Zelda is exclusive in this. Therefore, only with Zelda can we have such an in-depth look at the creations of a game and what decisions go into it, even if some of the things that are talked about were never the intentions of the developers. I also believe that finding the details of how Hyrule changes can help us to anticipate future findings in Zelda titles. Forgive me, as this initial post will seem all over the place with theories and ideas. But take not that each idea will be explored in more detail and receive full attention in one or more dedicated posts in the future. So without further ado, I present my rationale on why it is that I have chosen the order above:
It is no secret that SS is the first in line. It has been stated. Hell, it's on the back of the damn box. There are several pieces of information we can glean from even the basics of this title as to why the order is what it is. First, the names of the territories. With Faron forest and Eldin being in SS, we can deduce that TP is next. after all, people don't lose the names of a location and readopt it later. It is far more likely that those residing on the surface would keep the names of a location intact when discovered. So Faron forest is known in SS, and after the decent of the sky people to Hyrule, they keep the names of these locations. Only after millenia pass do these names change. But they do not disappear.
OoT calls this same forest Kokiri Forest, or the Lost Woods. But the residents of Hyrule have not forgotten the original name. Instead, they simply confused it over time. Faron was lost as a location, and was adopted as the name of a fabled earth goddess known as Farore. Just as the territory Eldin became known differently, but they kept the name Din as the fire goddess. Legends are often changed over many years, and here I find that it is no different. And Skyloft, the sacred home of the Goddess, became known as the Sacred Realm. Lost to time after the great migration to earth, the Sacred Realm contained the power of the three goddesses.
I feel as though this alone is evidence enough to determine the order of the games. After all, from just these assumptions, more deductions can be made.TP introduces the three spirits, and they exist within Hyrule. Link interacts with them directly. The goddess above may have split herself to govern the three kingdoms. This is the most uncertain part. Why do the deities change? This is a question that may not ever be entirely clear, but from TP on, the number stands as three. I believe that because of the great release of evil, the power of the spirits is slowly dying over time. So it is safe to assume that where in TP people can interact with these spirits as spirits, they continue to transform. By the time we encounter OoT, the deities each take a mortal form. The Deku Tree, Volvagia, and Jabu-Jabu. Each is the keeper of their realm. In WW, they are even weaker. The great tree in WW is not the incredibly wise Deku tree from OoT. He is more human, a fully featured face, and drowning under the ever-sinking earth. Valoo is not the mighty beast that Volvagia was, as he sits helpless at the top of a mountain. I believe that the gods of Zelda are dying with Hyrule, and that Link is summoned back to delay the inevitable.
Once evil breaches the world, that's it. There is no turning back. The corruption is choking the very earth, seizing all that there is. It cannot be stopped, only sealed briefly until is becomes too great for the gods to hold steady and spills out again. Thus, we summon Link to seal evil again. But each time we visit Hyrule, it is in greater disarray. SS sees Hyrule as a lush land with evil in it. TP shows us the evil dimension as it first invades Hyrule as a whole. In SS, evil erupts out of a rift, but the monsters are only part of what threatens the land. TP sees the evil realm itself attempting to swallow Hyrule completely. It mimics its very shape, and encapsulates it. By OoT, evil becomes one with the world. Gannondorf, evil manifest, corrupts Hyrule through tyranny. It is the first time that the land itself looks destroyed. Although SS has Hyrule separated, it is the goddess who does it. TP has Hyrule plunged into evil, but it is not transformed. OoT has the land of Hyrule actually tainted by becoming evil. And finally, WW showcases the death of Hyrule. The inevitable end of the world, where the weight of all the chaos is sinking it, plunging it below. The remains of Hyrule are mountaintops above the water, a last gasp for air before the world ends. And Ganon will not stop until Hyrule rest at the bottom of the cold ocean, and the gods grow weaker with every passing year. Ganon never loses strength. the gods show that they need another's aid.
There's my preview, and I hope I made you think. My favorite parts are coming, looking at the comparative anatomy of the creatures and how they evolve in Hyrule. How each race shifts and changes. Feel free to comment and spitball your ideas. But what I provide here is a sample of the firm foundation on my argument, and there's more to come. thanks for reading!